Retirement Is Not a Change Management Strategy — leadership article about organizational change management and resistance to change.

Leading through the messy middle between the organization you have and the one you say you want.

Most organizations I work with have two strategic plans. One is beautifully designed and presented at the annual retreat, full of words like innovation, collaboration, and excellence. The other is never written down, but everybody knows it by heart:

“Things will get better when Bob retires.”

“We just have to hang on until Susan leaves.”

“Once that department head is gone, maybe we can finally fix this.”

If that second plan sounds familiar, your organization has adopted attrition as its change management strategy. And if that’s the plan, you don’t really have a change strategy. You have a leadership courage problem.

Organizational change management isn’t about waiting for the people who resist change to disappear. It’s about helping the people you have move toward the organization you’re trying to become.

Why Organizational Change Meets Resistance

Leaders enthusiastically embrace better communication, stronger accountability, and healthier culture, at least in theory. Then the actual work begins. Someone has to change how they’ve done their job for 20 years. Someone has to learn a new process, accept feedback, or stop a behavior that’s been tolerated for a decade. People push back, complain, and remind everyone how long they’ve been there, and suddenly leaders get nervous. Change sounded wonderful as a vision. It’s far less appealing when someone is upset about it. If you’re wondering how that person went unaddressed for so long in the first place, I write about it in “Your Culture Is Whatever You’re Willing to Tolerate.”

When employees say nothing will improve until a certain person leaves, I think leaders should hear it as a warning. Not necessarily about that person, but about how much confidence the organization has lost in its leadership.

What they’re really saying is, “We don’t believe you’ll deal with this while they’re still here.”

Leading Through the Messy Middle of Organizational Change

There’s a gap between the old world and the new one. The old expectations no longer work, but the new ones haven’t become normal yet. Some people are excited, some anxious, some relieved that leadership is finally addressing a long-standing problem, and some are angry because the rules they were comfortable with are changing. During that stretch, the organization can feel worse than it did before anyone tried to fix anything. Hard conversations happen, relationships strain, and there may even be departures. That’s usually when leaders start wondering if they made a mistake.

Discomfort isn’t proof that a change is failing. Sometimes it’s proof that change is finally happening. Resistance can also expose real flaws in the change, so leaders have to listen, check whether the expectations are reasonable, and adjust when the evidence calls for it. But if the change is necessary and the process is fair, resistance alone shouldn’t get to decide whether you follow through.

Research also explains why “we already announced it” isn’t much of an answer for people struggling with change. In a study published in the Journal of Business and Psychology, Prashant Bordia and his colleagues examined employees in a public sector organization undergoing change. They sorted the uncertainty people felt into three types:

  • Strategic uncertainty: Where is the organization headed?
  • Structural uncertainty: How will the organization be organized?
  • Job-related uncertainty: What will happen to my role?

Clear communication from management reduced the first kind. It took something more to ease the other two: giving employees a real part in decisions about the change. People who had a say felt more in control of their circumstances and experienced less psychological strain, and that sense of control protected them from the stress of not knowing what would happen to their jobs. In other words, explaining where you’re going matters. But if you want people to feel steady in the middle of change, you have to give them a voice in how you get there.

How Leaders Balance Employee Reactions to Change

When I finally raised standards for my teams at Carolina Improv and Carmine Communications, after waiting longer than I should have, I watched the same decision land in two completely different ways. Some people on my teams were relieved. They wanted more consistency and teammates committed to getting better, and they were glad the expectations were finally clear. Others were genuinely disappointed. They’d grown comfortable with the old approach, the change affected opportunities they valued, and to them it felt like a loss. A couple of people didn’t meet the new standard, and even with development opportunities and other ways to stay involved, those decisions hurt. I wrote about why I waited so long in “Compassion Is a Lousy Excuse for Avoiding Hard Conversations.”

Both reactions were real, and both deserved consideration. But I couldn’t let disappointment decide whether the organization kept evolving. That’s the balance leaders have to strike: understanding people’s feelings without letting every feeling become a veto. A fair process doesn’t guarantee a painless outcome, and leaders who make “nobody gets upset” their measure of success will never lead anyone anywhere new.

Why Leaders Must Follow Through on Change

Organizations most often get stuck when leadership announces a new direction, resistance shows up, and leadership quietly retreats. The deadline drifts, the new standard fades, or an exception gets made for someone influential. Everyone instantly understands the real message: change is optional if you resist long enough. People who were excited about improving get discouraged, people who resisted learn it works, and trust in leadership ends up weaker than before anyone tried. That isn’t change management. It’s surrendering the future to the status quo.

None of this means becoming ruthless. Courageous leadership means explaining why expectations are changing, listening to concerns, offering training and coaching, considering accommodations, and recognizing that people adapt at different speeds. It means telling the difference between someone struggling to change and someone unwilling to try. But it also means recognizing when support has been given, expectations are clear, and continued avoidance is hurting everyone else.

The Three Kinds of Courage Change Requires 

In my experience, getting through the messy middle takes three kinds of courage:

  • The first is the courage to acknowledge reality, including your own role in letting things drift.
  • The second is the courage to initiate change by setting expectations, communicating them, and supporting people as they meet them.
  • The third, and the hardest, is the courage to stay the course when people are upset and you start doubting yourself, which means separating legitimate concerns that deserve an adjustment from the ordinary discomfort that comes with growth.

The messy middle is temporary. The damage from indefinite avoidance can last for years. If your organization’s real change management strategy is waiting for certain people to retire, resign, or move on, ask yourself: What are you waiting for?

Organizations don’t evolve when people leave. They evolve when leaders stop waiting.

If your organization is stuck in the messy middle of a change, I help leaders get through it without backing down or burning people out. Connect with me here: gina@ginatrimarco.com

This post is part of The Uncomfortable Side of Leadership, a series on the leadership conversations most of us avoid.

avatar
About the author

Gina Trimarco Klauder, MOL, SHRM-SCP, is a native of Chicago and CEO/Founder of Carmine Communications and Carolina Improv Company. She has 30+ years of experience in marketing, sales, operations, and people training, in addition to a Master's in Organizational Leadership. Gina combines street smarts and improv comedy skills with her experience in the corporate and entrepreneurial worlds, which sets her apart from her competition.

Related Posts