When including one person comes at everyone else’s expense, it isn’t inclusion anymore.
I believe in inclusion. People deserve dignity, respect, opportunity, and a real sense of belonging, and organizations should work hard to remove unnecessary barriers. I also believe something that makes people uncomfortable when I say it out loud: our efforts to include one person can create a deeply unfair experience for everyone else. Leaders need to be willing to talk about that, because the people quietly carrying the extra weight are part of the team too. Team accountability isn’t the opposite of inclusion. It’s part of what makes inclusion fair, because everyone deserves to belong to a team where their contributions are respected and the responsibilities are shared.
Wearing The Jersey Versus Doing The Work: Being on a Team Isn’t the Same as Being a Teammate
There’s a difference between wanting to wear the jersey and wanting to do the work of being on the team. People love community. They love performing, being recognized, and feeling like they belong, and all of that matters. But a spot on the team comes with obligations to other people. Your preparation affects your colleagues. So do your communication, your follow-through, and your willingness to take coaching. Belonging is not just about what the group gives you. It’s also about what you give back to everyone in it.
Picture a team where most people show up prepared, follow through, support each other, and accept coaching. One person repeatedly doesn’t. The others compensate, adjust, take on extra work, and slowly get frustrated. Leadership sees it and hesitates to act because that person might feel excluded. Now look at it from everyone else’s perspective. Are their contributions being respected? Is their experience of this team fair? If inclusion only accounts for one person’s experience and ignores the rest, we’ve defined it far too narrowly.
Researchers have a name for one version of this: social loafing, the tendency to put in less effort when working as a group than when working alone. In a review published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, psychologists Steven Karau and Kipling Williams combined the results of 78 studies and found that social loafing showed up across all kinds of tasks and people. It wasn’t inevitable, though. It shrank when each person’s contribution could be seen and evaluated, and when the work felt meaningful. That’s useful for leaders, because before you blame someone’s attitude, it’s worth asking whether you’ve made each person’s contribution clear, visible, and connected to the team’s success.
Why Team Accountability Matters, Even for Volunteers
Our improv performers at Carolina Improv Company are volunteers, and I value that enormously. But I flatly reject the idea that volunteering makes standards optional. Nobody is required to join our performing ensemble. Once you choose to join, though, other people are counting on you onstage. In improv, the most important question isn’t “how can I be funny?” It’s “how can I make my scene partner successful?” That means listening, accepting offers, following direction, showing up prepared, and practicing when you’d rather be doing something else. When one person ignores their partners or arrives unprepared, someone else has to carry the scene. The audience may never notice. The cast always does, even if they never say a word.
This applies far beyond theater. I see the same dynamic on volunteer boards, committees, and executive teams. A title, a long tenure, or a lot of enthusiasm cannot substitute for actually contributing to the people around you.
There’s another layer that makes this harder to spot. Not everyone on a team will tell you when someone isn’t pulling their weight. People with a more passive or conflict-averse communication style will often absorb the extra work quietly rather than risk tension with a teammate or look like they’re complaining. In DISC, the behavioral assessment I use with many of my clients, these are often people with a high Steadiness style: the calm, supportive teammates every team relies on. That’s exactly why they’re the most likely to carry the load without saying a word. Their silence doesn’t mean everything is fine. It means leaders have to pay closer attention, notice who keeps covering the gaps, and step in for them, because the people being burdened most are often the least likely to ask for help.
Workplace Inclusion Doesn’t Mean Every Role Is for Everyone
As we rebuilt both Carolina Improv and Carmine Communications after the pandemic, I realized we needed a clear line between participating in our improv community and serving on the performing cast and corporate training team. Being a cast member and trainer carries responsibilities: developing your skills, attending practices, supporting your partners, and contributing to the quality of shows and training contracts. That’s about commitment, not perfection. So we set clearer expectations for the team, and we also created a more casual format where people could enjoy learning and playing without taking on those commitments. Both are legitimate ways to belong. They just aren’t interchangeable. That line gets much harder to draw when someone has a long, loyal history with you, which I explore in “When Loyalty and Accountability Collide.”
This is where inclusion conversations get complicated, and where good leaders do the harder thinking. Is the expectation actually necessary for the role? Have we considered reasonable accommodations or another route to success? Have we offered training and coaching, and are we applying the standard consistently? Those questions are part of genuine inclusion. But treating everyone with equal dignity doesn’t mean giving everyone identical responsibilities. A person can be valued without being selected for a particular position, and a disappointing decision is not automatically rejection.
Check The Mirror First: Leaders Set the Standard for Team Accountability
Leaders also have to look honestly at their own part. Did we explain the commitments clearly from the start? Have we applied them consistently, or only to the people who were easy to hold accountable? Have we modeled the behavior we expect? If not, we helped create the confusion we’re now frustrated by. I write more about how leaders end up rewarding the very behavior they complain about in “Your Culture Is Whatever You’re Willing to Tolerate.”
When leaders repeatedly overlook one person’s behavior, the rest of the team stops volunteering, stops contributing, and eventually stops speaking up. The very sense of belonging leadership was trying to protect starts to erode, just in a different part of the room. That’s the paradox: an approach meant to create inclusion can quietly create exclusion for everyone doing the work. Belonging should never require anyone to prove their worth as a human being. But belonging to a team does carry responsibility to the people on it.
Before you make an exception for one person, have you considered what you’re asking everyone else to carry?
If you’re trying to balance inclusion with real accountability on your team, I help leaders draw that line fairly and clearly. Start the conversation here: gina@ginatrimarco.com
This post is part of The Uncomfortable Side of Leadership, a series on the leadership conversations most of us avoid.




