Twenty-Five Years of Service Is Not a Hall Pass — article graphic about long-tenured employees, accountability, and professional growth.

Loyalty deserves appreciation. It doesn’t buy a lifetime exemption from growth.

Congratulations on your 25 years of service. I mean that. You’ve survived leadership changes, restructurings, new technology, shifting priorities, and more than a few questionable initiatives, and your institutional knowledge is worth a great deal. But I do have one question, and I’d ask it of anyone with a long tenure, including myself. Have you grown for 25 years, or have you repeated the same year 25 times? Those are two very different careers, and they deserve very different conversations.

Long-tenured employees can be an organization’s greatest source of wisdom and stability, but experience becomes a liability when years of service are used to justify resisting change or avoiding accountability.

When Employee Tenure Becomes Entitlement

In nearly every organization I work with, I meet people who have held their positions for 15, 20, or 30 years. Many of them are extraordinary. They mentor newer colleagues, embrace new challenges, and help the organization navigate change because they’ve seen so much of it. Others seem to believe their years have earned them something else entirely: the right not to change, not to learn the new system, and to keep doing things the way they always have regardless of what it costs the people around them.

You can usually hear that belief in the way leaders talk:

“We’ve always let them do it that way.”

“They’ve been here forever.”

“That’s just how they are.”

When I hear those phrases in a client’s building, I know the problem isn’t one employee. It’s a set of expectations that leadership has been quietly reinforcing for years. See my article “Your Culture Is Whatever You’re Willing to Tolerate” for a deeper dive into how those unwritten rules take hold in organizations.

Resistance to Change vs. Legitimate Employee Concerns

Let me be fair to experienced employees, because not everyone who pushes back on a new process is being entitled. Sometimes they’re right. They’ve watched previous initiatives fail; they know why a system was built the way it was, and they spot risks that newer leaders miss. Any leader who dismisses that perspective is being foolish. But there’s a world of difference between “I have concerns about whether this will work” and “I’m not going to learn it because I don’t want to.” The first invites a conversation. The second shuts down growth.

Experience should make you more valuable to the organization, not less willing to evolve with it.

How Leaders Enable Entitlement in Long-Tenured Employees

The uncomfortable part for leaders is that long-tenured employees rarely create these expectations alone. We help. We grant exceptions, avoid conversations, and overlook behavior because someone has been around so long. Eventually, those exceptions start to feel like earned privileges. Then a new leader arrives and applies consistent standards, and the employee feels unfairly targeted. Is it really unfair to expect everyone to keep learning? Or was it unfair to everyone else all those years when expectations applied only to some people?

Leadership Experience Doesn’t Exempt Us From Growth

I’ve led Carolina Improv Company since 2008, and I can tell you plainly that the way I lead today isn’t the way I led back then. My standards have changed, my approach to feedback has changed, and so has my willingness to have hard conversations. I’ve avoided things I should have faced, reconsidered decisions, and changed my mind more than once. I hope I’m still doing all of that 20 years from now, because the day I decide my experience means I no longer need to grow is the day my experience becomes a liability. I can’t ask the people I lead to keep evolving while exempting myself.

Why Employee Loyalty and Accountability Must Coexist

Research supports respecting experience without treating it as a guarantee. In a review published in the Journal of Management, researchers Thomas Ng and Daniel Feldman combined the results of 350 studies covering nearly 250,000 employees. They found that longer-tenured employees generally performed their core jobs better and contributed more beyond their formal duties. But the boost from tenure got smaller the longer people stayed. More surprisingly, longer tenure was also linked to some counterproductive behaviors, including more aggressive behavior and more absences that weren’t due to illness. Experience has real value. It just doesn’t replace an honest look at someone’s current contribution, or the obligation to keep investing in their development.

Organizations should celebrate longevity. They should honor institutional knowledge and keep investing in experienced people’s development. They should also set clear expectations, provide real training and support, and learn to distinguish a legitimate barrier from simple unwillingness. They shouldn’t treat years of service as an automatic exemption from accountability. Someone with 30 years of experience can be one of your greatest assets, or the person whose refusal to adapt creates extra work for everyone else. The difference isn’t tenure. It’s what they’ve done with it. An employee who won’t grow is a very different situation from one who can no longer do what the role requires, and I take on that harder conversation in the article “When Loyalty and Accountability Collide.”

Your years of service deserve respect, and your current contribution still matters. So whether you’ve been somewhere three months or three decades, it’s worth asking yourself honestly: am I using my experience to move this organization forward, or to justify standing still?

If you’re leading experienced people who’ve stopped growing, I can help you have that conversation with respect and clarity. Reach out here: gina@ginatrimarco.com

This post is part of The Uncomfortable Side of Leadership, a series on the leadership conversations most of us avoid.

avatar
About the author

Gina Trimarco Klauder, MOL, SHRM-SCP, is a native of Chicago and CEO/Founder of Carmine Communications and Carolina Improv Company. She has 30+ years of experience in marketing, sales, operations, and people training, in addition to a Master's in Organizational Leadership. Gina combines street smarts and improv comedy skills with her experience in the corporate and entrepreneurial worlds, which sets her apart from her competition.

Related Posts