The gap between how we see ourselves and how other people experience us, and why your hurt feelings don’t settle the question.
Here’s a question most people would rather not sit with over morning coffee: “what if you aren’t as good at your job as you think you are?” What if you aren’t quite the communicator you believe you are, or as collaborative, or as easy to work for? What if the people around you can see something about your performance that you genuinely can’t? That gap between self-perception and actual impact is one of the most stubborn problems I run into in leadership development, and almost nobody believes it applies to them.
Leadership self-awareness isn’t simply knowing your strengths and weaknesses. It’s understanding the difference between how you think you’re showing up and how other people actually experience you.
Why We Struggle to Assess Our Own Performance
There’s research behind that blind spot. In a well-known review published in the Journal of Applied Psychology, psychologists Paul Mabe and Stephen West combined results from 55 studies comparing people’s ratings of their own abilities with other measures of their performance. If self-assessment were highly accurate, those two things would line up closely. They didn’t. The average correlation was just .29, indicating a relatively weak relationship between how people rated themselves and how their abilities were otherwise assessed. That doesn’t mean everyone overrates themselves, because plenty of people underrate themselves as well. It means your own read on your performance is an incomplete source of information, no matter how sincerely you believe it.
The Leadership Blind Spot: Intentions vs. Impact
People tend to evaluate their own performance by what they meant to do. I was trying to help. I thought I explained that clearly. I was just being honest. The meeting went great. But nobody else experiences our intentions. They experience our behavior. The leader who believes she’s an excellent communicator may be leaving her team confused every Monday. The colleague who thinks of himself as collaborative may interrupt people constantly. And the frustrating part is that they can be completely sincere about it.
Improv makes this painfully visible. A performer can get big laughs, walk offstage glowing, and genuinely believe they had a great show. Meanwhile, their scene partners spent the whole night chasing them, losing their own ideas, and doing the quiet work of holding the story together. From the performer’s chair, it was a triumph. From the stage, it was exhausting. Same show, two completely different experiences, and the performer had access to only one. Confidence and competence aren’t the same thing, and an audience laughing isn’t the same as being a good teammate.
Why Constructive Feedback Feels So Personal
When someone tells us we’re not performing as well as we believe, they’re poking at a story we’ve built our identity around. I’m a good leader. I’m a strong communicator. I’m the one people depend on. So we defend ourselves. We question the messenger, explain why they misunderstood, fixate on the one comment that was off, or reject the whole thing. Usually that isn’t arrogance. Sometimes it’s embarrassment, sometimes fear, and sometimes we simply don’t know what we don’t know.
This is where I want to be blunt. How feedback makes you feel tells you something real about what it was like to receive it. It tells you almost nothing about whether it’s accurate. Feeling hurt doesn’t make feedback wrong, and delivering it with confidence doesn’t make it right. Those are separate questions, and most of us collapse them into one the moment our ego gets bruised.
How to Recognize Patterns in Feedback
I tell our team members that feedback is often subjective. One director will love a character choice on stage that another would cut, and neither is wrong. So don’t build your self-image around a single remark, good or bad. Look for what keeps showing up. If three different people, in three different settings, are describing the same behavior, that’s no longer just one person’s opinion. That’s a pattern worth examining. You don’t have to agree with every piece of feedback to learn from it, but dismissing everything that doesn’t match your self-image is a dangerous habit that can stall an otherwise brilliant career.
The responses that move people forward are surprisingly simple:
Instead of “that’s not fair,” try “can you give me an example?”
Instead of “that’s not who I am,” ask “is that how I came across?”
And when something lands hard, ask yourself the most useful question in professional development: what if there’s some truth in this? Not “what if I’m terrible” or “what if everyone secretly hates me,” just “what if there’s something here I haven’t been able to see?” That one shift replaces defensiveness with curiosity, and curiosity is where growth actually starts.
Leadership Self-Awareness Is a Skill You Can Develop
After every improv show, our directors ask performers what went well and what could have gone better. It sounds simple, and it isn’t. Some people can’t see their strengths, others can’t see their weaknesses, and many are far harsher on themselves than anyone else would be. With practice, though, people get better at noticing the gap between what they intended and what others experienced, and they become less dependent on someone else to tell them. That’s not just an improv skill. It’s emotional intelligence, and it’s trainable in any organization willing to make it a habit. I share how we built that habit at Carolina Improv, and why it took years, in my article “A Safe Space Is Not a Feedback-Free Zone.”
Self-awareness isn’t about constantly finding fault with yourself. It’s about seeing yourself more accurately, and sometimes that means discovering strengths you underestimate, too. But the most dangerous performance gap you have may be the one you’re absolutely certain you don’t have. You can’t improve what you’re unwilling to see. Seeing the gap is only the first step. If you want to know what to do once you’ve seen it, read my article “Talent Is Optional. Coachability Isn’t.”
So, how often do you ask someone how you actually come across, and really want the answer? If you’d like a clearer picture of how your leadership lands, I work one-on-one with leaders to close that gap. Reach out here: gina@ginatrimarco.com
This post is part of The Uncomfortable Side of Leadership, a series on the leadership conversations most of us avoid.




