What leaders can do to help people grow, and the part only the individual can choose.
I’ve worked with remarkably talented people who were nearly impossible to coach, and I’ve worked with people who were never the strongest performer in the room but became the teammate everyone wanted. The difference almost never came down to raw ability. It came down to whether they were willing to learn. If I had to pick between a gifted person who can’t hear feedback and a solid person who can, I’d take the second one every time, and so would most of the leaders I work with once they’ve lived with the first kind for a while.
What Research Says About Coachability at Work
I’m not the only one who thinks so. In 2023, researchers Ian Katz, Caroline Moughan, and Cort Rudolph combined results from 46 studies covering more than 12,000 workers to examine what they call feedback orientation, essentially how open a person is to hearing feedback and using it. Their findings, published in Human Resource Management Review, showed that people who were more receptive to feedback tended to perform better at work, care more about learning, and feel more satisfied in their jobs. That doesn’t prove coachability beats talent in every role. It does suggest that being open to hearing how you’re actually doing is more than a pleasant personality trait. It shows up in the work itself.
Coachability Requires Humility and Accountability
Coachability takes two things that people often confuse. Humility lets you say, “I might have missed something.” Accountability asks, “So what am I going to do about it?” You need both. I’ve met plenty of people who can acknowledge a weakness gracefully and then change nothing. I’ve also met people who work incredibly hard while refusing to consider how their behavior lands on others. Neither one is actually coachable, even though both would tell you they are.
At Carolina Improv Company, the improv theater and training school I’ve run since 2008, we started assessing our performing ensemble against clearer standards. Every performer received feedback and a development plan, including those who comfortably met expectations. That was deliberate. Meeting a standard doesn’t mean you’re finished growing, and I didn’t want anyone to think the plans were punishment reserved for those who fell short. What surprised me was how differently people responded. Some were disappointed but curious about their feedback, and they came back with questions and ideas. Others had a hard time accepting that the way they experienced a performance could be very different from the way their ensemble teammates experienced it. Those two reactions told me more about each person’s future with our company than the assessment itself did.
I see the same thing in many of the organizations I work with. Everyone is working on the same project, but each person focuses on their own piece, with little awareness of what their contribution actually looks like to everyone else. The project gets finished because, together, they get it done. But for the people doing the heavy lifting, getting there was harder and far less fulfilling than it needed to be, often because of one or two people who never realized they were the ones slowing everything down. That kind of obliviousness is real, and it’s more common than most leaders think.
How Leaders Can Develop Coachable Employees
I have strong opinions about motivation, and here’s the biggest one: you cannot reach inside another person and install the desire to improve. You can inspire it. You can show people possibilities they hadn’t considered and make growth much easier to pursue. But the person still has to participate, and no amount of leadership energy substitutes for that.
That is not a free pass for leaders, though. There’s a great deal we control. We can make feedback specific instead of vague. We can demonstrate the skill, give people room to practice, and make the process fair. We can ask how someone prefers to hear feedback and keep certain conversations private. We can build an environment where admitting a mistake doesn’t cost anyone their dignity. At Carolina Improv, it took years of modeling that behavior before people started sharing their struggles openly instead of treating every note as an insult. We didn’t manufacture anyone’s motivation, but we changed the conditions around learning, and that changed what people were willing to try. I tell the fuller story of building that culture in “A Safe Space Is Not a Feedback-Free Zone.”
When Employee Development Becomes Chasing
There’s a real difference between someone struggling to learn and someone declining to engage. The first person may need patience, new tools, or a completely different way of being taught. The second needs a clear conversation about responsibilities and consequences. Before you decide which one you’re dealing with, stay curious, because fear, embarrassment, a poorly explained expectation, or an inaccessible process can all look a lot like resistance from the outside. Ask before you assume.
Once you’ve clarified the expectations and offered reasonable support, the person still has a choice to make, and you have to let them make it. I’ve watched leaders exhaust themselves caring more about someone’s growth than that person does. They schedule another check-in, rewrite the plan again, and take on a little more of the person’s work every month. That isn’t support anymore. It’s chasing, and it sends a message to the rest of the team about whose effort actually counts.
Leaders Must Model the Coachability They Expect
The hardest part of this for me was recognizing that I couldn’t ask my team to evolve while refusing to evolve my own leadership. I had to stop avoiding difficult conversations, set clearer standards, and trust that people could handle honest feedback. Some performers embraced the challenge, and some found it genuinely hard. That’s what leading real human beings looks like. I wrote about the moment I finally admitted my own avoidance in “Compassion Is a Lousy Excuse for Avoiding Hard Conversations.”
You don’t have to be the most talented person in the room, and you certainly don’t have to be perfect. But you do have to be willing to ask, “What can I do better next time?” and then actually do something about it. Leaders can provide the feedback, encouragement, tools, and opportunities, but they can’t supply someone else’s willingness to grow. At some point, the responsibility shifts to the individual.
So, here’s my question for leaders: Are you creating the conditions for people to grow, or exhausting yourself trying to make them want to?
If you’re tired of wanting someone’s growth more than they do, let’s talk about what’s in your control and what isn’t. Connect with me at gina@ginatrimarco.com.
This post is part of The Uncomfortable Side of Leadership, a series on the leadership conversations most of us avoid.




