Psychological safety is supposed to make honest conversations possible, not make them disappear.
Somewhere along the way, a lot of organizations started confusing psychological safety with emotional comfort, and I think it’s quietly making teams worse. Psychological safety and feedback should go hand in hand, but too often organizations treat them as competing priorities. I hear leaders say they want people to feel respected, included, and valued, and I’m all for it. But in practice that goal often gets translated into a set of unspoken rules: don’t say anything that might upset someone, don’t challenge anyone too directly, and whatever you do, don’t give feedback that could sting. Since when did feeling safe mean never feeling uncomfortable?
Improv Is a Laboratory for Psychological Safety and Feedback
I’ve spent much of my career teaching improvisation, and it’s a fascinating place to watch human behavior. People volunteer to walk onstage with no script and no guarantee of success. They take risks, they make mistakes, and every so often they bomb spectacularly. Then they do something most organizations struggle with. They sit down afterward and talk honestly about what happened. Our directors lead a conversation about what worked and what could have been better, performers name their own strengths and gaps first, and the director fills in what they couldn’t see. The point isn’t criticism. It’s learning.
I’d love to tell you that culture appeared naturally. It took us years to build, and we’re still working on it. At first, plenty of performers struggled to hear feedback in front of their peers. Some got defensive, some were brutally hard on themselves, and some honestly couldn’t identify a single thing they would do differently. If that sounds like your last round of performance reviews, it’s because I see the exact same reactions in organizations across every industry I work with. I get into why we get so defensive, and what to do about it, in my “You’re Probably Not as Good as You Think You Are” article.
Why People Get Defensive About Feedback
Most people don’t resist feedback because they don’t want to improve. They resist it because they hear it as a judgment of who they are instead of information about what they did. So that’s what we worked on, as a team. Everyone received feedback, including our most experienced people. Everyone was expected to reflect on their own performance. Our senior performers modeled how to give and receive critiques, and we started adapting the approach to the person instead of forcing one method on everyone.
That last piece matters more than leaders realize. People receive feedback very differently. Some want it direct and immediate, others need time to process, and some are fine discussing their work in a group while others do much better one-on-one. We now ask performers how they prefer to hear feedback, and we take the answer seriously. Sometimes a group conversation is necessary because everyone needs to understand what happened. Sometimes a private conversation is more respectful and far more effective. The standard never changes. Only the delivery does, because the goal is development and not discomfort for its own sake.
What Psychological Safety Actually Looks Like at Work
This distinction isn’t just my opinion. Amy Edmondson, the Harvard researcher whose work put psychological safety on the map, studied 51 work teams and found that psychological safety went hand in hand with team learning. Notice how she defined it: a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk-taking. That’s a very different promise from “nothing uncomfortable will ever happen here.” Admitting a mistake, asking for help, and talking honestly about what needs to improve are exactly the risks a safe team makes possible.
A truly supportive team doesn’t pretend everything is wonderful when it isn’t. It’s a place where someone can admit a mistake without being humiliated, where questions and disagreement are welcome, and where someone can say “I struggled with that” and hear a teammate answer “I’ve been there, here’s what helped me.” I’ve watched that develop in our ensemble. When a performer owns something they could have done better, their castmates now jump in with encouragement and their own stories. It’s supportive, and it’s honest at the same time, and nobody has to pretend to be perfect. But being supported never means being exempt from getting better.
I remind our performers regularly that receiving feedback doesn’t mean they aren’t good. It means there’s room to improve, which is true of everyone I’ve ever met. You can be talented and still need coaching. You can be respected and still miss the mark. Your performance is not your identity, and feedback about your behavior is not a verdict on your worth. When people really absorb that, they ask more questions, admit mistakes faster, take more creative risks, and start helping each other improve without being asked. What separates the people who grow from the ones who stall is the subject of my “Talent Is Optional. Coachability Isn’t” article to learn more about this.
The Real Test
The measure of a psychologically safe team isn’t whether everyone feels comfortable all the time. It’s whether people can have honest, sometimes uncomfortable conversations without fear of humiliation or retaliation. That takes trust, compassion, and leaders who model what they expect, including a willingness to hear things they’d rather not.
A safe space isn’t a place where nobody challenges you. It’s a place where you can be challenged without being diminished. Here’s my question for leaders: have you built a culture where people feel safe enough to hear the truth, or one where everyone has simply learned not to say it?
If your team is “nice” but not honest, I help leaders build feedback cultures where people can hear the truth without losing their footing. Let’s talk about your team: gina@ginatrimarco.com
This post is part of The Uncomfortable Side of Leadership, a series on the leadership conversations most of us avoid




