Compassion Is a Lousy Excuse for Avoiding Hard Conversations
Sometimes what we call kindness is just us protecting ourselves from an uncomfortable afternoon.
I want to start with a confession, because I’ve earned the right to write this one the hard way. I have given someone another chance, and then another, and then one more, and told myself the whole time that I was being compassionate. I wasn’t. I was avoiding a conversation I didn’t want to have, and I had found a very flattering word for it.
Apparently I’m in good company. In research published in Harvard Business Review, leadership development experts Jack Zenger and Joseph Folkman surveyed 7,631 people and found that 44% considered giving negative feedback stressful or difficult. In a separate self-assessment of 7,808 people, 21% admitted they avoid giving it altogether. Those numbers don’t tell us how many of them called it compassion the way I did. They do tell me that the discomfort on the leader’s side of the table is far more common than most leaders will admit out loud.
After nearly two decades running an improv theater and years of consulting with organizations on leadership and organizational health, I’ve come to believe that much of what passes for compassion in the workplace is really avoidance with good manners. And the people who pay for that avoidance are rarely the ones we think we’re protecting. They’re everyone else.
The bill always lands on someone
Most leaders want to be good people. We want to be supportive and fair, and those instincts are admirable. The trouble starts when supportive quietly turns into permissive. We let missed deadlines slide because someone is going through a rough patch. We tolerate the same performance problem for the third year in a row because the person has been around forever. We skip the correction because we know they don’t take criticism well. Then we congratulate ourselves on our empathy.
The question we almost never ask is who else is absorbing the cost. When one person misses deadlines, a colleague picks up the slack. When one person won’t learn the new process, everyone else builds workarounds. Over time, your most dependable people become your most burdened people, and then leadership sits in a meeting wondering why morale is slipping. I’ve been in that meeting with clients more times than I can count, and I’ve also been the leader who caused it.
What it looked like in my own house
When I reopened Carolina Improv Company after the pandemic, I wanted people to reconnect and feel the joy of performing again. If I’m being completely honest, I also wanted it to be easy for me. I was building my consulting practice at the same time, and lighter standards meant less to manage, fewer hard conversations, and more room on my calendar. So I relaxed standards that had been part of our ensemble for years, and at first it felt generous. Some performers threw themselves into rehearsing, learning, and supporting their teammates. Others treated it far more casually. Different skill levels were never the problem; that’s normal in any group. The problem was different levels of commitment, and I let it go on far longer than I should have because I didn’t want to disappoint anyone.
Eventually I had to admit something unflattering. I wasn’t protecting those few performers so much as I was protecting myself, both from their disappointment and from the time and energy it would take to hold the line, and in the process I was failing everyone who was showing up and doing the work. Choosing the standard that’s easiest for the leader to manage, instead of the one the team needs, is a leadership decision too. I just didn’t want to call it that. That realization reshaped how I lead, and it sits underneath most of what I now teach about leadership.
You don’t have to choose
I reject the idea that leaders have to pick between compassion and accountability. Compassion means recognizing that people have different circumstances, abilities, and needs. Accountability means recognizing that their choices still affect other people. Compassion might look like extra training, a different way of delivering feedback, coaching, an improvement plan, or finding a role where someone can actually succeed. It does not look like quietly erasing the expectation. Accountability, for its part, never requires humiliation or coldness. You can care deeply about someone and still tell them their work isn’t where it needs to be, and very often that honesty is the most caring thing anyone has done for them in years.
Saying no without losing your heart
Some leaders treat the word no as a failure of empathy. It isn’t. Telling someone they aren’t ready for a responsibility is a statement about readiness, not worth. A respectful no gives someone real information to grow from, while a vague yes or an endless maybe keeps them hoping for something you already know isn’t coming.
If you’re going to say no, talk about the actual expectations rather than personality, share specific observations, and listen to their side. Ask yourself honestly whether training or an adjustment would change the picture. Offer a path forward or another way to contribute, if one exists. And please don’t soften the message so much that they leave the room unsure what you decided. I’ve done that too, and it’s crueler than the clear version. If the person across the table has given you years of loyalty, that conversation gets even harder, which I take on in “When Loyalty and Accountability Collide.”
The message everyone else receives
Every time a leader overlooks a recurring problem, the whole organization is watching. People notice who gets held accountable and who doesn’t, and whose work gets quietly redistributed to them. When leadership talks about excellence and tolerates mediocrity, people stop believing the standards are real. That’s the moment an individual performance problem becomes an organizational health problem, and it’s much harder and more expensive to fix than the conversation you were avoiding. I dig into how those quiet exceptions become the real rules in “Your Culture Is Whatever You’re Willing to Tolerate.”
The next time you feel the pull to let something slide because you don’t want to hurt someone, ask yourself two honest questions: 1) Am I helping this person grow, or protecting myself from an uncomfortable conversation? 2) Who else is being affected by my decision not to act?
If there’s a conversation you’ve been putting off and you’d like a thinking partner before you have it, I’d be glad to talk. Connect with me here: gina@ginatrimarco.com
This post is part of The Uncomfortable Side of Leadership, a series on the leadership conversations most of us avoid.




